Z-Wave Developers Journey Part 8

Antennas for Z-Wave

This is an abbreviated version of the full blog on the Z-Wave Alliance website.

Introduction

The antenna is the most important element of a wireless IoT product. A well designed and tuned antenna means the product “just works” in most customers’ home. A poorly designed antenna that has not been tuned will result in one-star reviews and quickly get on the “products to avoid list”. Fortunately, there are a lot of resources to help engineer an antenna that fits the needs of your product. This post goes over the many antenna options and some of the best practices to get the best RF performance.

Hub Antennas are Critical

Early in my Z-Wave consulting career I assisted a company who had recently added Z-Wave to their Smart Home controller using a plug-in expansion board. The tiny board with a 500 series Z-Wave chip had a 20-pin header to the motherboard. The problem with this plug-in board was that the antenna was positioned in the center of the 8×6 inch motherboard. The antenna was also just a simple 7 mil trace around the edge of the PCB with the ground plane just a couple of millimeters away and had no impedance matching circuitry. This was about as bad an antenna as I have seen. Their customers complained the controller had only about 10 feet of RF range which I quickly confirmed. The CEO of the company stated that the RF range didn’t matter since Z-Wave is a mesh so it will find a route to all the other devices in the home. While the mesh will help, it does mean that at least one device with a decent antenna was required to be placed next to the controller. The poor range meant every command had to be repeated, resulting in latency and excess Z-Wave traffic that tended to clog the network when many commands were sent in sequence (for example at sunrise or sunset). My solution was to flip the PCB around and place the antenna against the edge of the plastic enclosure and increase the size of the ground plane of the plug-in board. Once I tuned the PCB antenna, the RF range met the Z-Wave certification requirement of 40 meters and customer complaints dropped dramatically. Unfortunately, the poor RF range gave Z-Wave a bad reputation in the vendors community. The problem was their poor antenna design and not the Z-Wave protocol itself. Key take away: Always design the very best antenna possible especially when designing a controller. See the Home Assistant ZWA-2 for the best antenna design I have seen.

Antenna Types

I often quote that even a paperclip soldered to the pin of a Z-Wave module will meet certification requirements of 100 meters of RF range. While I haven’t actually tested this, I have worked on so many antennas that it does seem it will work. There are many types of antennas and below is just a partial list. Do you have a unique antenna? I’d like to see it! Send me an email with a photo and how far it can reach.

PCB

PCB antennas are the most common Z-Wave antenna due to their low cost and simple design. All you need is a little extra PCB space and to follow a few simple design rules. PCB antennas include simple L, meander, inverted F, fractal and more than I can possibly list here.

The early Zensys developers kit recommended a simple L shaped antenna shown here from the datasheet. This antenna works well and easily achieves the required performance for Z-Wave certification. The one challenge with all PCB antennas is that the radiation pattern is not uniform and often has nulls and gain in certain orientations. Remember that the regulatory requirements will identify the orientation with the strongest signal. If that orientation has antenna gain, you may have to reduce the transmit power to stay under the regulatory requirements. Lowering the transmit power will reduce the RF range in all other directions. Z-Wave certification will check the RF range in all 6 orientations. You may need to redesign your PCB antenna to make the radiation pattern more uniform. Antenna redesign can be a time consuming and expensive process.

The Inverted F antenna is popular with 2.4GHz antennas as it has good performance and is small. But in the 900MHz band the antenna is large as shown here. If you have PCB real estate, it can be a good option. The thing I have a hard time wrapping my head around is that the antenna is connected directly to ground. Seems like that would short it out, but instead it anchors the resonant standing wave so it works but needs to be carefully tuned.

Meander antennas are commonly used in space constrained applications. A meander antenna simply folds the wire back and forth a number of times to compress the PCB space required. The Silicon Labs BRD4205 has an example meander PCB antenna which is selectable by installing a 47pF capacitor and removing the one for the SMA connector.

Wire

Wire antennas fall into two broad categories: flexible and stiff. Flexible antennas as the name implies, is a simple stranded wire cut to a specific length. The wire is ideally held in a known orientation using plastic standoffs but there are many products that are stuffed into a wall box with the antenna stuffed alongside all the other wires. The problem with flexible wires is that it is impossible to account for the impedance shift due to adjacent materials. The length is also hard to consistently manage in manufacturing as even a one-millimeter variation can change the antenna performance. A simple wire is low-cost and works reasonably well especially for space constrained applications.

The second category is a stiff wire or stamped metal. The wire is typically pre-cut and bent at the factory with precision and then hand soldered in place. This results in a repeatable and predictable environment meaning it is possible to accurately tune the antenna for optimal performance. The other advantage is that the antenna is usually held vertically off the PCB ground plane yielding a better radiation pattern than a PCB antenna. The antenna can be stamped metal in any shape allowing for more flexibility in optimizing performance as shown here.

Helical

Helical antennas can be quite small but can have decent performance if properly tuned. The Z-Wave UZB USB stick controller uses a small helical antenna as shown here. The challenge with making the antenna so small is to understand that the ground plane is also part of the antenna. Thus, a tiny ground plane reduces performance. The other problem with USB sticks is that they are often plugged directly into a PC or a Raspberry Pi. A computer has many components and oscillators that generate a significant amount of RF noise. In addition, the orientation may be less than optimal. The recommendation is to put the USB stick on a USB cable of at least one foot in length. The cable isolates the USB stick from the noise from the computer and allows more optimal orientation.

Chip

I personally have not had good experience with chip antennas, but I am aware of companies that have used them successfully. Chip antennas are often the smallest antenna thus they are often used in very space constrained products. The challenge is that they are impacted by the nearby environment. The antenna must be carefully tuned with the enclosure, battery and mounting surface included in the tuning.

External

External antennas, often called whip antennas, are usually connected via an SMA or U.FL connector on the outside of the enclosure. External antennas can yield the best performance because the antenna is omnidirectional and has a donut shaped radiation pattern resulting in some gain. They are typically the most expensive option and are normally only used by the controller or by a device that needs long range. Don’t be fooled into believing the claim that the antenna is 50-ohms and “tuned” for your chosen frequency. You must still tune it. I tested all the antennas shown here and they vary widely in performance. The more expensive antennas were not the best. In fact, one of the cheaper antennas nearly matched the performance of the best antenna. However, one of the popular antennas turned out to be terrible. The Home Assistant ZWA-2 uses a giant screw-in antenna and has by the far the best RF range of any device I’ve tested.

Can One Antenna Work for All Regions?

Yes. One antenna can work for all regions – from 868MHz to 920MHz. But you need an antenna with sufficient bandwidth to do it. For optimal performance, slightly different Pi network component values are required for each end of the spectrum. The recommendation is to optimally tune the antenna for the primary target market with perhaps a shift towards a secondary market. For example, if the primary market is the US (908-920MHz) and the EU is secondary (868MHz), tune the antenna for 908MHz or slightly lower. Even if the antenna isn’t optimally tuned, it will still work if the bandwidth is wide enough.

Antenna Best Practices

  • No metal within 6mm of the antenna
    • Ground plane, batteries, enclosure
  • Impedance matched and tuned for target market with enclosure
    • Including typical installation surface within 6 inches
    • VSWR below 2 at target frequency
    • Initial PCB antennas are 10% longer than calculated to ease tuning
  • Continuous ground plane(s) with array of vias
  • RF signals on a single layer and surrounded with ground vias
  • Measure the radiation pattern in all orientations
    • Prevent strong gain in one orientation resulting in failing regulatory testing

Next Steps

Part 9 of the Z-Wave Developer’s Journey discusses the regulatory process for subGHz devices in the US. I will present the tests you should perform before going to a test house and the tools you’ll need. As we continue along the Z-Wave Developer’s Journey, I welcome your comments and questions.  Please feel free to reach out to me directly via email.

Leave a Reply